By David Kowalsky, Guest Editor
Do you ever find yourself overwhelmed with trying to keep track of all the versions of a document that are being sent back-and-forth by you and your work colleagues by email? When opening a document to edit, have you ever had the experience of being frustrated by immediately seeing a message pop up telling you that the document is locked? Many companies have introduced features to their products to alleviate these types of issues, making collaborative authoring– projects where written works are created by multiple people together (collaboratively) rather than individually – more attractive and worth investigating.
Document editing is frequently done collaboratively, especially now that it is so typical for companies to have documentation and engineering team members located at different locations throughout the world. Some products even promote editing with real-time technology. But it can be confusing to read marketing material that uses a variety of different terms including, but not limited to: co-authoring (Microsoft), collaborative multi-person editing (Google Cloud Connect for Microsoft Office), and multiple user, online editing (IBM LotusNotes with eXpresso). Each are referring to essentially the same thing: the ability to edit the same document, at the same time, by multiple people at different locations.
The purpose of this article is not to rate the products, but instead to introduce what is available by listing the key product details, with the intention of encouraging further investigation. The majority of the products listed below fall into the category Document-centric Authoring, but there are other tools available to help you collaborate on documents, which are in a second category, Other Tools for Collaborating. Finally, there is Purpose Specific Solutions.
What about the future? It is already apparent that collaboration is not stopping with documents. Wikis are becoming more widespread, but even more intriguing is the start up Convofy and Chatter (from SalesForce), which are both pushing for companies to implement private social networks where collaboration in real-time is used for as many workplace functions as possible.
Google Docs enables multiple people in different locations to collaborate simultaneously on the same document, spreadsheet, or presentation from any computer with Internet access. Users can see edits in real time. Up to fifty people can edit a document at the same time.
Cost: Google Apps: Up to 10 custom accounts for free. Google Apps for Business: Get added controls and features for $5 per user per month.
- Google Docs in Plain English (video)
- Google Docs Sharing and Collaboration Tutorial (video)
- Learn more about using Google Docs (web page)
Google Cloud Connect for Microsoft Office
Google Cloud Connect for Microsoft Office is a free plug-in for Microsoft Office 2003, 2007, and 2010 that lets you share and edit Word, PowerPoint, and Excel documents simultaneously with other people. You get the collaboration benefits of Google Docs, while still using Microsoft Office.
Cost: Plug-in is free. Google Apps: Can get up to 10 custom accounts for free. Google Apps for Business: Get added controls and features for $5 per user per month.
Microsoft Office 2010: Word, PowerPoint, and OneNote
Microsoft Office 2010: Word, PowerPoint, and OneNote (via shared notebooks) co-authoring capabilities enable you to simultaneously edit the same Word 2010 documents and PowerPoint 2010 presentations. This is after saving and then opening a file online to SharePoint 2010 (business users) or SkyDrive(everyone else).
When someone else opens the same file for editing while you have it open in Word 2010 or PowerPoint 2010, from the same SharePoint or SkyDrive location, you automatically begin a co-authoring session. Automatically see who else is editing and where they are working in the document. Save the document to see changes from other editors as you work. Your changes also become available to other editors each time you save.
When simultaneously editing files with others in Word 2010, the paragraph you are currently editing is automatically blocked to other editors to avoid conflicts. You see who is editing the paragraph and can view their presence (the formal term for availability information – contact card information) and initiate contact from their as well.
If someone makes changes to the same copy of the document when they have it offline, their changes automatically sync the next time they are online and you then see those changes as well.
- Document collaboration and co-authoring (article)
- Co-Authoring in Word 2010 (video)
- Share notebooks in OneNote 2010 (web page)
- 20-Dec-2010 entry of The Microsoft MVP Award Program Blog (blog post)
- Office 2010 Product Guides (download Word, PowerPoint, and OneNote Product Guides)
- The Secret Life of Word: A Professional Writer’s Guide to Microsoft Word Automation (book) [XML Press]
Microsoft Web Apps: Word, Excel, and OneNote
Microsoft Web Apps: Word, Excel, and OneNote allows you to post the content that you create in PowerPoint, Word, Excel, and OneNote on your desktop to a Microsoft SharePoint 2010 site (for businesses) or a Windows Live SkyDrive folder (for everybody else). Then access, view, edit, and share those files from almost any computer with an Internet connection. When others open the same file (in a Word , Excel or OneNote Web App) , everyone can edit at the same time.
Cost: For consumers, Office Web Apps are free on Windows Live, by the use of a free Windows Live ID. For business customers, purchasing a volume license edition of Office 2010—Office Professional Plus 2010 or Office Standard 2010—includes a license for the Office Web Apps. Business customers can then install and run Office Web Apps on SharePoint 2010.
Additional information :
- Now available: Co-author documents in the Word Web App (blog post)
- Work together on Office documents in SkyDrive (web page)
- Office 2010 Product Guides (download the Microsoft Office Web Apps Product Guide)
- Windows Live SkyDrive (website)
Microsoft Office 365
Microsoft Office 365 is a suite of office collaboration and productivity tools delivered through the cloud. Available in range of service plans to meet the needs of businesses of all sizes.
For plans that include Office Web Apps:
You can simultaneously edit Excel Spreadsheets and OneNote notebooks with others in real time, and see exactly who is editing and viewing your documents. View, edit and share content created in the Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and OneNote desktop applications online, from almost any device with an Internet connection.
Cost : For professionals and small businesses Plan P: $6 Per user/month . For midsize businesses and enterprises (discounts are available for customers who want to purchase volume licensing). Enterprise Plans (E1-4) from $10-27 per user/month. Kiosk work plans (K1 – K2): from $4-10 per user/month. Office 365 for education: Contact a Microsoft accent representative or partner. Can also add individual Office 365 services Office Professional Plus: $12 per user/month Exchange Online: Plan 1: $5 per user/month. Plan 2: $10 user/month. Exchange Online Kiosk: $2 per user/month. Exchange Online Archiving: $4 Per user/month. SharePoint Online: Plan 1: $5.25 per user/month, Plan 2: $10.25 Per user/month. Lynch Online: Plan 1: $2 per user/month. Plan 2: $6.50 Per user/month. Office Web Apps: Plan 1 $11.25 per user/month. Plan 2: $16.25 Per user/month.
Box.net is integrated with Google Docs, so you can create Google Docs and Google Spreadsheets within Box and share with others for real-time editing. As a cloud solution, there is no hardware to buy or software to install. User permissions and IT settings ensure secure management of all files.
Cost: Business (3 users minimum); $15 per user/month. Enterprise. Call +1.877.729.4269 for pricing.
- Watch Demo (video – top right of the page. Click “Play” below the “W” icon)
- Box+Google Docs – Accelerating the Cloud Workforce (video – bottom of the page)
- Box and Google Docs: Accelerating the Cloud Workforce (web page)
Agilewords is designed for online document reviews. Uses the old model of serialized collaboration: check out a file, edit, save, and check back in. Only one person at a time can edit a document offline while in review (in Microsoft Word 2003 or newer) and then re-upload. Limited to basic online editing (content update – no formatting). It is not an online word processor; you cannot create a table, add headings, or insert images, even though it lets you update documents offline. Get email notifications sent to your inbox every time authors edit content. Includes a Document Review Wizard to upload a document, setup a review, and invite collaborators.
Cost: Free: 1 Author, 3 documents Individual: $19 per month. 1 Author. Unlimited documents. Custom domain. SMB: $49 per month. 3 Authors, Unlimited documents. Custom domain.
- Watch Demo (video – click “play” icon below “Review & Approve Documents”)
Zoho Docs uses the old model of serialized collaboration: check out a file, edit, save, and check back in. Prevents users from overwriting each other’s changes. After check-out of a document, you save it locally to your desktop to edit.
Cost : Free Edition. 1 GB space. Standard Edition: $3 per user/month. Premium Edition: $5 per user/month.
Zoho Office for SharePoint 2003 and 2007
Zoho Office for SharePoint 2003 & 2007 stores documents in SharePoint; can easily be edited by right-clicking and opening the document in Zoho. By default, documents are opened for editing in a collaboration mode. The document is checked out to the user who opens it first. Other users who open the document can collaboratively contribute to the document. Only the first user can save the content back to the SharePoint library.
Cost : Free Plan: Free 30 Days (Trial). Monthly Subscription: $3 per user. Yearly Subscription: $24 per user.
WordPerfect Office X5
WordPerfect Office X5 (Standard and Professional) provides integration with Microsoft Office SharePoint Server (MOSS) 2007, using the old model of serialized collaboration: check out a file, edit, save, and check back in. Instead of checking files in and out through web browsers, the interface is built right into WordPerfect. When checking out a document, a copy of the document is saved to a “working folder” where you can revise the document and save the changes locally without sharing them with others. When you are ready to share your changes, check the document back in to the document library, making it accessible to others.
Cost: Professional (Full): $279.99 per user. Standard (Full): $179.99 per user.
- WordPerfect X5 – Microsoft SharePoint (video)
- Integrating with Microsoft Office SharePoint Server (web page)
- Introduction to Microsoft Office SharePoint Server 2007 (web page)
Adobe Acrobat X Pro
Adobe Acrobat X Pro provides integration with Microsoft SharePoint 2007/2010, using the old model of serialized collaboration: check out a file, edit, save, and check back in. Access SharePoint from any Acrobat Open or Save dialog box.
Cost: Acrobat X Pro full version from $449. There are separate stores at Adobe.com. Adobe Store for home and home office. Education Store for students, educators, and staff. Business Store for small and medium businesses.
For SharePoint | SharePoint 2010 pricing see: How to Buy
Other Tools for Collaborating
Serna Enterprise Edition
Serna Enterprise Edition provides collaborative XML authoring features; users can work with XML documents shared on a WebDAV-enabled server. The Serna XML editor supports annotative redlining features for the review of XML documents with seamless XML editing, discussion, and approval of XML content.
Cost : Starts at $749 per license for 1-5 licensed users. Price per license goes down – if buy for more users. There is also a one month free trial available.
Additional information :
Adobe Acrobat X
Adobe Acrobat provides shared online document reviews and collaboration.
Email Review : Sent by an individual or initiator of a group. Each person in the group sends their sticky notes, text edits, and markups to the initiator. All comments are merged into one PDF file to complete the review. Reviewers do not see each other’s comments unless the initiator merges all the comments and emails them to the team. Requires Acrobat or Reader versions 6 or later.
Shared Review/Collaborate Live: A secure way for internal and external members of a team to conduct an online review of any PDF document. Gives all the reviewers an opportunity to see everyone’s comments and give feedback. Reviewer commenting tools include: sticky notes, shapes, highlighters, lines, and stamps. First choose the reviewers and set a deadline. Then let Acrobat publish the shared document either using Acrobat.com’s free hosting services, or your own internal server. Must provide a free Adobe ID and password.
Acrobat X is required to initiate, track and manage a shared review. Only Acrobat X Pro users can enable those with the free Acrobat Reader to participate and add comments in a shared review.
Collaborate Live: chat and page view sharing. In an online session, remote users view a PDF document with a live chat window. Everyone sees the same part of the document.
Cost: Acrobat X Pro full version from $449. Adobe Reader X is free (download).
There are separate stores at Adobe.com. Adobe Store for home and home office. Education Store for students, educators, and staff. Business Store for small and medium businesses.
Getting Started: The Basics of Reviewing (video)
Google Docs Chat
Google Docs – Chat feature allows you and another collaborator to editing or commenting upon the same document at the same time, a box with the name of the collaborator appears at the top of the screen. If other people are editing or commenting upon a document simultaneously with you, you’ll see their edits and comments in real time. You can also see their names listed at the top. Click the arrow to the right of the names to open a tab where you can chat with other collaborators within the document.
Cost: See the above section for Google Docs
Microsoft Office 2010: Word, PowerPoint and OneNote via Shared Notebooks – Instant Messaging
Microsoft Office 2010: Word, PowerPoint, and OneNote via Shared notebooks – instant messaging(see “Co-authoring in Word and PowerPoint”) allow you to, depending on your instant messaging software, view information about current editors of a document and initiate communication with them from the Microsoft Office Backstage view.
To see contact card information (including availability information, also called presence) and communicate with other current editors from Word or PowerPoint, they need to be contacts of yours in your default instant messaging program. Supported programs for viewing presence and initiating IM conversations include Windows Live Messenger and other programs that support IMessenger.
If you use Microsoft Lync Server 2010 with Microsoft Lync 2010 (or Microsoft Office Communications Server 2007 R2 with Microsoft Communicator 2007 R2 or another application that supports IMessengerAdvanced), you can see presence information and initiate IM or voice calls from within Word 2010 or PowerPoint 2010, and can also utilize these communication options from Backstage view.
Cost : See the above section for Microsoft Office 2010: Word , PowerPoint, and OneNote via Shared notebooks
Zoho Docs Chat
Zoho Docs – Chat feature is a built-in Chat feature that allows real-time discussions about the document across users in different locations. No need to install a separate client for chat.
Private Chat – You can chat by sending private messages to an individual while working simultaneously, which makes your work fun and interesting.
Group Chat – Zoho Docs offers Group Chat, where you can invite your friends, family members, colleagues, etc., and share your message with them. They can also share their views and ideas simultaneously and can collaborate in real-time.
Cost : See the above section for Zoho Docs
Microsoft Office 365 Instant Messaging for SharePoint
Microsoft Office 365: instant messaging for SharePoint; instant messaging for Lynch Online — Plans that include SharePoint Online enable real-time communication with colleagues from within SharePoint Online. Project Professional 2010 synchronizes task status with SharePoint 2010 to enable effective project collaboration with teams.
Plans that include Lync Online: Connect with others through instant messaging (IM), video calls and online meetings. Move easily from instant messaging into ad-hoc online meetings that include audio, video, and screen sharing with just a few mouse clicks.
- Conduct online presentations to customers and colleagues including audio, video, screen sharing, and a virtual whiteboard.
- Invite external contacts to easily join online meetings through a native or web-based client.
- View presence status and click to communicate from within Microsoft Outlook, Office SharePoint, and other Office applications.
- Communicate with external organizations running Lync using IM, audio and video through Lync federation. Connect with Windows Live Messenger contacts using IM, audio and video calls directly from Lync.
Cost : See the above section for Microsoft Office 365
Versly(Now part of Cisco) integrates collaboration capabilities via a plug-in into Microsoft applications, allowing collaboration around content in documents, email, presentations, and spreadsheets. Cisco acquired the company in August 2011. At that time, the announced plan was to integrate the Versly technology with Cisco’s Quad (enterprise social software platform), Jabber (IM and presence/UC client and service), and WebEx (web conferencing).
Cost: Not available
MindTouch TCS (Technical Communication Suite) provides a collaborative authoring environment that lives in a web browser. Both customers and employees can work together on creating content. It is not a document authoring system; does not provide the ability to create files, such as Word documents. Instead, use to create topics or pages that live in a product support center or online help for a company customer support knowledge base.
Cost: Request a quote
- What is MindTouch TCS? (video)
Convofy is a private social network for companies. Share content with a team of people and communicate in real-time over that content. Annotate and collaborate on images, files, text, and the whole web with team members. Use chat or comments to attach context and send out messages to your team. Everyone in a company can join the private network. Only a work email address is needed.
Cost : The Basic version is free. The Premium version is $5/user/month.
Chatter is a private social network/business collaboration tool for people who work together at the same company or organization. Connect with your coworkers and share business information securely and in real-time. Updates on people, projects, and files are automatically pushed to you. Anyone with an email address that has the same company domain can join.
About the author
David Kowalsky is a technical writer for NEC Corporation of America in Bellevue, Washington. He is a senior member of the Society for Technical Communication‘s Puget Sound Chapter where he regularly writes book reviews for the Sound Views newsletter. In his spare time he enjoys running and reading. He can be reached via email or you can follow him on Twitter.